Celebrities who Failed to impress fans with their 2026 Oscars afterparty looks

The 2026 Oscars afterparty brought plenty of glamour, but not every celebrity managed to win over fans with their fashion choices. While some stars dazzled effortlessly, others faced unexpected criticism for looks that missed the mark. From underwhelming gowns to bold outfits that divided opinion, these celebrities left fans less than impressed on one of Hollywood’s biggest nights.

1. EJAE

EJAE made a major impact at the 2026 Oscars, earning recognition both as a performer and an award winner after the global success of the Netflix animated film KPop Demon Hunters.

She celebrated her big night at the after-party with her fiancé, producer Sam Kim.

For the occasion, EJAE stunned in a custom Christian Dior gown. The design featured an asymmetric silhouette with feather detailing in a rich, luminous shade. The intricate craftsmanship complemented her Oscar trophy perfectly as she posed for photos.

2. Jessica Alba

Jessica Alba chose a bold look for the celebrations, wearing a strapless black sequined gown by Tamara Ralph.

The dress showcased a corset-inspired bodice and was decorated with floating 3D diamond coque feathers around the skirt, creating a striking visual effect. She completed the outfit with black heels from Alexandre Birman, styled by Dani Michelle.

Reactions online were divided. Some fans questioned the unusual design, with one comparing it to a cartoon-like look, while others felt the decorative elements resembled insects and distracted from her overall elegance.

3. Kim Kardashian

Kim Kardashian attended the after-party alongside Kris Jenner, Kendall Jenner, and Kylie Jenner for a glamorous family night out.

She wore a custom gold gown by Gucci, fresh from Milan Fashion Week and designed by Demna. The long-sleeved dress hugged her figure and shimmered under the lights.

She paired the look with towering platform heels from Pleaser, which reportedly made walking difficult throughout the evening.

Online reactions leaned critical. While many praised the gown’s fit, several comments focused on her hairstyle, suggesting it detracted from the overall look. Others joked about the impracticality of her outfit, especially the shoes.

4. PinkPantheress

PinkPantheress stepped away from her signature Y2K streetwear style, embracing a more vintage-inspired aesthetic.

She wore a custom black gown by Tamara Ralph featuring a strapless, figure-hugging silhouette. The look was paired with a dramatic wide-brim hat and mesh kitten heels.

While the overall outfit was praised for its elegance, many critics pointed out the shoes as a weak element, saying they disrupted an otherwise polished appearance.

5. Quenlin Blackwell

Quenlin Blackwell played a key role at the Vanity Fair Oscars Party, co-hosting the livestream with Brittany Broski and Jake Shane.

She wore a white floral gown by Chanel from the Spring 2026 collection. The dress featured colorful 3D floral embellishments and a softly flared hem, creating a delicate yet eye-catching silhouette.

During the livestream, she interviewed major celebrities at the event, which was held at the Los Angeles County Museum of Art.

6. Keke Palmer

Keke Palmer embraced a regal aesthetic at the after-party in a purple velvet gown by Gucci.

The long-sleeved design featured bold hip cutouts, combining sophistication with a modern edge. She styled her hair in a sleek side-parted pixie cut and kept her makeup minimal, highlighting her eyes with signature winged eyeliner.

Her accessories were understated, including diamond drop earrings and a mix of gold and silver bracelets, allowing the dress to stand out.

While many praised her look, some online commentary shifted toward her appearance, with a few viewers making speculative and critical remarks about her facial features.

7. Olivia Rodrigo

Olivia Rodrigo showcased a playful, coquette-inspired outfit on the carpet.

She wore a custom mini dress by Saint Laurent, designed by Anthony Vaccarello. The look included a pale pink bandeau top and a voluminous feathered bubble skirt, finished with an oversized silk bow at the waist.

Despite its whimsical design, the outfit received widespread criticism online. Many fans felt it missed the mark, calling for a change in styling direction. Others specifically criticized the color choice and her eyebrow styling, suggesting both detracted from her overall appearance.

8. Hailey Bieber

Hailey Bieber made a solo appearance on the silver carpet, as her husband Justin Bieber was reportedly busy in the studio preparing rehearsals for his upcoming 2026 world tour.

The Rhode founder stepped out in a custom leopard-print gown by Giorgio Armani, styled with a sleek silver choker necklace.

Her look sparked mixed reactions online. While some viewers described the outfit as “underwhelming,” others even accused her of borrowing inspiration from other celebrities’ styles.

One harsh comment read, “Always trying to hide fridge bod,” while another simply called the dress “boring.”

9. Cara Delevingne

Cara Delevingne delivered one of the evening’s most daring and widely discussed fashion moments with a bold, unconventional look.

She wore a striking muscle-inspired dress designed by Thom Browne for his Spring/Summer 2026 collection, featuring a dramatic optical illusion bodice.

The sheer, long-sleeved mesh top was embellished with a trompe-l'œil male torso crafted from red, white, and navy crystals, creating a visually intense effect.

She balanced the look with a simple black floor-length skirt, allowing the intricate crystal detailing to remain the focal point.

Her brunette hair was styled in a sleek ponytail with side-swept bangs, completing the edgy aesthetic.

Not all reactions were positive, with one critic asking, “Why the ice capades costume?”

10. Emma Chamberlain

Emma Chamberlain attended the 2026 Vanity Fair Oscar Party in an outfit styled by Jared Ellner.

She wore a gown from Valentino’s Pre-Fall 2026 collection, pairing a red lace-trimmed tank top with a low-rise, art-deco-inspired sequined silver skirt.

Her look was elevated with canary-yellow opera gloves, adding a bold and unexpected pop of color that contrasted sharply with the rest of the ensemble.

A critic joked, “Trying to impress dishwasher trade,” reflecting the divisive reception of her outfit.

11. Kris Jenner

Kris Jenner made a glamorous appearance alongside her daughters and partner Corey Gamble for a stylish family outing.

She chose a floor-length black tulle gown from Valentino’s Spring/Summer 1995 Haute Couture collection.

The dress featured layered ruffle detailing and a voluminous ballgown silhouette, which she complemented with an elegant updo and sparkling diamond jewelry, creating a timeless and refined look.